Human Rights & Animal Welfare: The Controversial Mexico Bullfighting

 

Bullfighting resumed in Mexico City on Sunday at Plaza México, the world’s largest bullfighting ring. The fights had been suspended for over a year following an animal rights group’s successful legal challenge, but the nation’s highest court recently ruled they could restart pending a final decision on their legality.

The resumption was controversial as debates continue around animal welfare and public safety concerns. Still, many fans were excited for the return, greeting the first bullfighter, renowned Mexican Joselito Adame, with enthusiasm as six bulls were fought.

Outside, roughly 300 animal advocates peacefully protested with signs decrying the “murderers.” Police monitored as tensions occasionally flared between pro- and anti-bullfighting crowds. Activist Guillermo Sánchez was distressed by the cruelty to bulls while protester Alfredo Barraza hopes Mexico City will curb such violent spectacles.

Meanwhile, attendee Aldo Palacios enjoyed celebrating his birthday with family inside the arena’s festive atmosphere. In May 2022, a local judgment paused fights after a human rights group’s complaint, but the high court then permitted their interim resumption until ruling on potential harms to animals.

Animal protection groups have found growing success curtailing bullfighting elsewhere in Mexico. However, advocates for ranchers, businessmen and the estimated $400 million annual industry emphasize impacts to livelihoods and jobs if banned. The bull breeders association aims to cultivate new fans, especially youth. Debate continues on sociocultural traditions versus ethical views.